Verify Before You Share
A 3-MINUTE METHOD TO EVALUATE HEADLINES, POSTS, IMAGES & CLIPS
MAGIC Stands For:
Motive
What do they want you to think, feel, or do right now?
Audience
Who is being targeted? Which identities or emotions are being pressed?
Gimmick
What technique is doing the persuading (selective edit, false choice, scary chart, etc.)?
Incentive
Who benefits materially (money, power, attention, donations, ad revenue)?
Corroboration
Do primary sources or independent outlets confirm the core claim?
The 3 Minute MAGIC Flow:
Snapshot
Note the date, source, and URL. Take a quick screenshot.
M — Motive
State the claim in one sentence. Ask: What outcome are they pushing (click, share, donate, vote, rage, comfort)?
A — Audience
Who is being addressed (you/we/they)? Is it micro targeted? Check 'Why am I seeing this ad?'
G — Gimmick
Run the quick checklist:
- Selective clip or missing context
- False dichotomy or forced choice
- Truncated axes or unlabeled units on charts
- Whataboutism or shifting goalposts
- Firehose: many rapid claims, no sourcing
- Cheapfakes or deepfakes: odd lighting, lip sync, jump cuts
- Bot or amplification tells: identical phrasing, brand new accounts
- Recycled images or screenshots of screenshots
i — Incentive
Follow money or attention: donations, affiliates, merch, ad farm layout, political gain, status or reach.
C — Corroboration
Find the full transcript, filing, dataset, or vote record. Confirm with 2 or more independent outlets. If you cannot verify, do not share.
Red Flag Pause List
Quick Score (optional)
Give each letter a score from 0-2
10 Tool Starter Kit
Search Operators
Use site:, quoted phrases, minus terms (see Cheat Card)
Extras
Search Operators - Pocket Cheat Card
""-OR()site:inurl:intitle:filetype:before: / after:..related:cache:source: (News only)Live Demo Queries (Swap in Your Topic)
"prepared remarks" OR "full transcript" intitle:transcript (speaker) (event)(bill number OR case name) filetype:pdf site:congress.gov OR site:courts.gov(topic) -opinion -editorial -substack -medium -reddit -x.com(topic) (city OR county) after:2025-06-01 site:.gov OR site:.news(topic) filetype:xls OR filetype:xlsx OR filetype:csv site:.gov OR site:.edu"quote fragment here" -twitter -x.comInteractive MAGIC Test Tool
The MAGIC Pledge
I will pause.
I will check.
I will share only what I can stand behind.
Presenter: AJ - The Ripon Rabbit — Magician, Historian, Broadcaster